The company presentation at each of the core schools, in advance of the interview dates, by team captains. The chance for informational interviews in advance of the official ones. The testing for culture fit for the candidates What is your evaluation of the process used by the firm, what are strong points and what are weak points? State your argument. My personal evaluation of the process used by SG Cowen is that it is a very demanding process which consists of a structured and stringent plan for making hiring decisions.
A very strong point of the process is Ray’s approach in that by focusing to the next 15 top schools you can find more loyal and competitive students. Additionally, by doing the informational interviews, the team captains can distinguish the students who really want to be prepared for the official interviews. Another positive point is that the candidates do not depend on one-vote decisions. Furthermore, the company’s CEO is present and provides support by giving speeches to attract new employees.
On the other hand, there are some weak points in the process. Decision makers want to finish the procedure as quickly as possible, as the event is organized in their free time. This may lead to the wrong choice of candidates. Additionally, there is a potential bias in the selection process, due to personal preferences of the bankers and due to time constraints. Lastly, when some candidates have the chance for informational interviews, they have an unfair advantage, in the process, against their competitors.
Which two candidates would you select if you were a member of the recruitment committee? Explain your answer by reflecting on the criteria Cowen uses to select suitable candidates. If I was a member of the recruitment committee, I would based my choices to the criteria of the firm, by finding candidates who are functional and cultural fit for the company. I believe that the most suitable candidate is Natalya Godlewska. Her main strength is her strong work experience and credentials and she is one of the most competitive applicants the committee has seen.
I agree that it is too easy to use “culture” as an excuse and I believe that once Godlewska feel comfortable with co-workers she will be a great asset to the company. Furthermore, I believe that Andy Sanchez would, also, be a great asset to the company because of his entrepreneurial and working experience. Although, he has a low GPA, his SATs and GMATs compensate it and as he stated, his low grades are a reflection on the amount of work he had while he was running his business.